Skip to main content

Oswego Election Controversy Legal Bills Adding Up

Feb 04, 2015 09:13PM, Published by Steven Jack, Categories: Community, News




The legal bills in the Oswego election ballot battle that played out in November, December and January have started arriving at Village Hall. 

According to documents obtained by Only Oswego, the village currently owes nearly $53,000 between the three law firms involved in the matter. The total is for November and December only, and Village President Brian LeClercq said this week he fully expects the final tally to eclipse $100,000 when January’s bills are added to the total. 

“Let’s put this in perspective,” LeClercq said. “This is money that could have funded 35 percent of our current ash tree replacement program. That’s what kind of impact this will have.”

The largest portion of the legal bills belongs to the village’s law firm of Ottosen, Britz, Kelly, Cooper, Gilbert & DiNolfo. Itemized election billable hours total about $30,000, the documents show.

The village owes the firm of Hervas, Condon & Bersani $16,650. Partner Charles Hervis represented the village’s Electoral Board throughout the legal proceedings. 

Finally, $6,380 is due to the firm of Ancel, Glink, Diamond, Bush, Dicianni and Krafthefer. Partner Keri-Lyn Krafthefer represented Village Clerk Tina Touchette.

“All this was done at the expense of the taxpayers,” LeClercq said. “Everyone in Oswego loses. We can point fingers if we want and say it was this person’s fault or that person’s fault, but what I want is to move forward and hear from these candidates to find out what they are going to do to lead our community.”

Controversy background

The legal wrangling over the April election began in November after a July resolution passed unanimously by village trustees changed the village's election process to non-partisan. Non-partisan elections require a November filing period and a possible February primary if enough candidates file. 

Former Village President candidate and Trustee Terry Michels and Trustee candidate Diane Selmer were the only two to file during the filing period for non-partisan elections that ended Nov. 24. 

Several other candidates who are running for village offices believed they had until Dec. 22 to file their petitions, as has been past village practice and was stated in the village’s candidate election packet and on its website.

Those candidates who filed during the December filing period are Village Trustees Tony Giles and Gail Johnson for village president, and trustee candidates Ryan Kauffmann, Karin McCarthy-Lange, Joe West, Brian Thomas and Rasma Motykowski.

After a series of candidate petition objections, the village’s Electoral Board ruled Jan. 5 that all candidates should appear on the April 7 ballot. About one week later, village trustees voted to file suit against the village and county clerks to force 23rd Circuit Court Judge Stephen Krentz to determine the April election process. 

Krentz ruled Jan. 21 the village had no legal authority to change its election process without a referendum, forcing the village to hold a partisan election and allowing all candidates on the ballot.

Less than a week after the ruling, Michels dropped out of the race, saying he didn't want the election controversy to be a distraction "from the truth and real issues that this campaign should be about.”

In a statement, Michels blamed the costs incurred by taxpayers on trustee candidate West, who was the first to file election petition objections against Michels and Selmer. West shot back days later, saying he and his lawyers made several attempts to settle the matter with Michels, but Michels refused. 


Like what you're reading? Subscribe to Only Oswego's free newsletter to catch every headline



Oswego Election battle Election battle costs


  • $45 Spring Cleanups

    03/30/2017
    12:00AM

    We Scoop Dog Poop! Now offering Spring Cleanups starting at just $45! Sign up for our Weekly or B...


  • DISCOVER SCOTLAND

    03/30/2017
    09:00AM

    The Oswego Senior Center is sponsoring a trip to Scotland April 17-26, 2017. Cost is $3,649 per p...


  • Matter of Balance

    03/30/2017
    01:00PM — 03:00PM

    Many older adults experience concerns about falling and restrict their activities. A Matter of Ba...


  • Fabyan Villa Museum & Japanese Garden open

    03/30/2017
    01:00PM — 04:30PM

    The Fabyan Villa Museum and Japanese Garden will return to a public hours schedule starting on Su...


  • $45 Spring Cleanups

    03/31/2017
    12:00AM

    We Scoop Dog Poop! Now offering Spring Cleanups starting at just $45! Sign up for our Weekly or B...


  • Sign Language Class

    03/31/2017
    09:00AM — 10:00AM

    Do you have trouble hearing? Always saying, “What did you say?” Get support and learn a new way...


  • Broadway musical meets sci-fi horror in this dark musical comedy. What happens when Seymour Krelb...


  • $45 Spring Cleanups

    04/03/2017
    12:00AM

    We Scoop Dog Poop! Now offering Spring Cleanups starting at just $45! Sign up for our Weekly or B...


  • Matter of Balance

    04/03/2017
    01:00PM — 03:00PM

    Many older adults experience concerns about falling and restrict their activities. A Matter of Ba...


  • Pivot Points

    04/03/2017
    04:30PM — 05:30PM

    A pivot can refer to many things - traditionally, the point of rotation in a lever system, the c...


  • $45 Spring Cleanups

    04/04/2017
    12:00AM

    We Scoop Dog Poop! Now offering Spring Cleanups starting at just $45! Sign up for our Weekly or B...


  • CULINARY EXPO

    04/04/2017
    11:00AM — 01:00PM

    Join us at the Oswego Senior Center, 156 E. Washington Street, to explore the foods of the world ...


  • The Martin Luther High School Concert Choir and Troubadours from Greendale, Wisconsin will presen...


  • FILM: "A SMALL ACT"

    04/04/2017
    07:00PM — 09:00PM

    When Hilde Back sponsored a young, rural Kenyan student, she thought nothing of it. She certainly...


  • $45 Spring Cleanups

    04/05/2017
    12:00AM

    We Scoop Dog Poop! Now offering Spring Cleanups starting at just $45! Sign up for our Weekly or B...


  • Wednesday Walking Club

    04/05/2017
    08:00AM — 09:00AM

    Wednesdays, April 5–October 25, 8–9 AM Free drop-in program for all ages Get fit the old-fashio...


  • Wednesday Walking Club

    04/05/2017
    08:00AM — 09:00AM

    Wednesdays, April 5–October 25, 8–9 AM Free drop-in program for all ages Get fit the old-fashio...


  • HISTORY AND HERITAGE (NEW!)

    04/05/2017
    10:15AM — 11:30AM

    Join Mike Adolph, a retired History teacher, for this 8-week history series. This series will exa...


  • Fabyan Villa Museum & Japanese Garden open

    04/05/2017
    01:00PM — 04:30PM

    The Fabyan Villa Museum and Japanese Garden will return to a public hours schedule starting on Su...


  • Jumpstart

    04/05/2017
    03:00PM — 05:00PM

    Know what you want and where you're going? Just need a little help in getting there? JUMPSTART ...


  • Are you interested in finding out more about the Batavia Mothers' Club? Please join us for our Ap...